The Newcomer's Dark Secret

Reddit, what is the creepiest dark secret you discovered about a local newcomer

in your town? I lived in a fog covered town when Julian moved in.

He was charming and handsome. We started dating, and everything seemed perfect until I

visited his secluded cabin in the woods. While he was out,

I found a loose floorboard. Underneath was a box of old IDs.

Each ID belonged to a woman from a different state who had gone missing years

ago. My heart stopped when I saw a recent photo of myself at

the bottom of the pile. I heard his car pull up. I had to